Ben Higgins Dating the Other Woman in Robby & Amanda’s Relationship — Report
Premiere Party For The Bachelor Charity – Arrivals
Credit: Michael Tullberg/Getty Images    

Ben Higgins

Ben Higgins Dating the Other Woman in Robby & Amanda’s Relationship — Report


Bachelor Nation is known for being incestuous, but this is taking things to the next level.

As fans know, the big franchise drama of this week has been Amanda Stanton and Robby Hayes’s messy breakup after Bachelor in Paradise Season 4.

However, we had no idea this alleged cheating scandal would somehow tie into Ben Higgins’s love life!

Back in late July, rumors spread that Robby cheated on Amanda at a concert in Colorado.

That was brought up during the BIP reunion, and later seemingly corroborated by a photo the single mom posted to Twitter.

That’s where Ben comes in…

The woman in question is Lindsey Duke, who knew Robby from when they both lived in Florida.

A post shared by LINDSEY DUKE (@linds_duke) on

Apparently, the two had even hooked up in the past, and rekindled things that night at the Zac Brown Band show.

Fast forward to Labor Day weekend when former Bachelor Ben was guest bartending at Sloan’s Lake Tap and Burger in his native Denver to help raise money for Hurricane Harvey victims.

Spoiler king Reality Steve is now reporting that Lindsey was also seen at the event, and the two even left together!

The blogger says he’s received photos of the two together from onlookers, where they were looking particularly cozy.

A post shared by Ben Higgins (@higgins.ben) on

If that’s not confirmation enough, fans also spotted them at breakfast together the next day.

“They are definitely spending time with each other,” Steve writes, adding that he’s unclear about their dating (or hookup) status.

A post shared by LINDSEY DUKE (@linds_duke) on

Either way, the Colorado-based gal has a history with Bachelor guys — and we’re not even finished yet.

RS is also reporting that, two weeks prior to her night with Robby, she hooked up with Bachelorette Season 8 winner (and Kristina Schulman’s ex) Jef Holm!

The iHeartRadio Summer Pool Party – Backstage
Credit: Ethan Miller/Getty Images for iHeartMedia    

Interestingly, it’s likely she met Jef through Robby, who rooms with him back in L.A.. Guess friends really do share everything.

If Lindsey and Ben do turn into something serious, at least she has experience dating men in the public eye.

Always a good time with this guy @bbortles5

A post shared by LINDSEY DUKE (@linds_duke) on

When she was a student at University of Central Florida three years ago, she dated star football player Blake Bortles, who is now quarterback for the Jacksonville Jaguars.

Small world, eh?