‘Pretty Little Liars’ Season 7: Did Noel Kahn Really Have Sara Harvey’s Phone?
Sara Harvey
Credit: Eric McCandless/Freeform    

Pretty Little Liars

‘Pretty Little Liars’ Season 7: Did Noel Kahn Really Have Sara Harvey’s Phone?


When Hanna went rogue to stalk her prime “A.D.” suspect Noel Kahn, she watched him toss Sara Harvey’s phone in the garbage.

NEWS: 4 Key Suspects in Sara Harvey’s Murder on PLL

But according to eagle-eyed fans of Pretty Little Liars, Sara Harvey was calling the phone, it wasn’t actually hers.

Of course, Sara is dead — and not in the “Alison is dead” or “Mona is dead” way. So some fan theories think another suspect in her murder was calling the cell Noel trashed from Sara’s phone.

NEWS: Uh Oh, a PLL Character Will Die in Summer Finale

Why? Check out this screenshot:

Sara Harvey’s Phone

At the bottom of the screen it says, “Slide to Answer.” Anyone with an iPhone knows this means that someone is calling the phone. We could assume that the caller ID popped up a photo of Sara, the caller.

Of course, the other answer is that someone is calling Sara’s phone coincidentally, and she happens to have a weird non-selfie picture of her own face as everyone’s caller ID and her backdrop.

NEWS: Maya Reference on PLL Season 7 Might Mean Answers

Not that we’d put anything past the mysterious Sara Harvey.

Suspicious Noel never admitted the phone was Sara’s, he just asked to see it before grabbing it away from Hanna. Why did Hanna immediately assume the phone was Sara’s? Has she used a phone before?

NEWS: Prepare to Wait for PLL’s Mary Drake Child Reveal

Was this just a Pretty Little Liars mistake, or does it mean someone other than Noel Kahn is carrying the late Sara’s phone?

Pretty Little Liars airs Tuesdays at 8 p.m. ET on Freeform.

Check out more of Wetpaint's coverage of Pretty Little Liars below:

Is Charlotte Still Alive on Pretty Little Liars?
A Major Character is Returning for the PLL Summer Finale

Pretty Little Liars Season 7 Summer Finale: Everything We Know
This PLL Fan Theory is a Huge Alison Twist
Jenna is Getting a Surprising Love Interest in Season 7
Did Hanna Kill Rollins on Purpose?