\'Pretty Little Liars\' Twin Theory: How Could It Still Be in Play?
Sara Harvey as Red Coat
Credit: ABC Family/Eric McCandless    

Pretty Little Liars

‘Pretty Little Liars’ Twin Theory: How Could It Still Be in Play?


Color us intrigued. Pretty Little Liars showrunner Marlene King just took to Twitter to drop a hint that the ever-popular twin theory is still in play. We thought that, with the reveal of “A” in the summer finale, the theory that someone has a secret, evil twin was out the window. Apparently, not so much. Check out what Marlene wrote…

NEWS: PLL Showrunner Marlene King Responds to Haters

So, what does this mean for the future of PLL? How could the twin theory still be in play? Here’s what we think…

Bethany Young Could Have a Twin

As we head into a new story arc for this show, two big questions remain: Who killed Mrs. DiLaurentis? And what the heck was up with Bethany Young? Though we technically found out more about Bethany in the summer finale of PLL, we still have a lot of questions about the girl who ended up dead in Ali’s grave. Where did she come from? What was her relationship like with Mrs. DiLaurentis? Why did she escape that night? We think these questions might be answered in the winter season, and they might lead to the reveal that Bethany Young had a twin. If this is the case, might she be seeking revenge against CeCe and everyone she loves? It could explain what happened to Mrs. DiLaurentis. It would also be the perfect new mystery, as it links back to the old one in compelling ways.

NEWS: Why Is This Pretty Little Liars Star All Just Dressed Up?

Sara Harvey Could Have a Twin

There is another wild card still involved in the game and her name is Sara Harvey. Though we found out that Sara was both Red Coat and the Black Widow, and had been helping CeCe enact the “A” game for awhile, we never found out why. Could she have been helping because she, too, had a grudge against the DiLaurentises? We know that Mrs. D. was on the board of trustees at Radley. Could Sara and/or her sister have been a patient there? Though this may seem a little out in left field, we’re dying to figure out the connection between Sara and the “A” game, and a secret twin could be the clue to everything.

Sara Harvey Is Bethany Young’s Twin

Our favorite theory? Sara Harvey is Bethany Young’s twin. It would explain how CeCe and Sara met one another, and would explain why Sara signed onto the “A” game to begin with: the get revenge for her sister’s untimely death. If this is the case, then we wouldn’t be surprised if Sara was the one who killed Mrs. DiLaurentis (obviously, without CeCe’s knowledge). Did Sara take Mrs. D. out because she blames her for what happened to her sister? We’ll have to wait until the winter season (or possibly beyond) to find out.

Check out more of Wetpaint's coverage of Pretty Little Liars Season 6 right here:


All The Answers Revealed — “A”, Red Coat and More

Who is “A” on Pretty Little Liars?

Pretty Little Liars Season 6 Finale Recap: “A” is Revealed!

Showrunner Marlene King Answers More PLL Questions
9 Questions We Still Have About Pretty Little Liars
5 Ways the Pretty Little Liars "A" Reveal Doesn't Make Sense

Is Pretty Little Liars Transphobic?

The Best Friendship Moments on PLL Season 6

Alison's 11 Best Moments on Pretty Little Liars

What Happens in the PLL Season 6 Winter Episodes?

There’s a “Troubling New Adventure” Coming to PLL

VIDEO: See The Liars in Five Years!

Is Hanna Engaged After the Time Jump?